When you purchase an independently reviewed book through our site, we earn an affiliate commission.
By Kawai Strong Washburn
SILENT WINDS, DRY SEAS
By Vinod Busjeet
Humanity has never stopped moving. Since the beginning of the species, we’ve continually migrated, until there isn’t a square foot of Earth that hasn’t felt our presence. The reasons have varied widely — from following the seasons to fleeing collapsing societies, and everything imaginable in between — but if we have one truth, it is nomadism.
Migration and its opportunities are at the heart of Vinod Busjeet’s debut, “Silent Winds, Dry Seas.” The novel is narrated by Vishnu, a young man of Indian descent who has grown up in Mauritius under British colonial rule in the 1950s and 60s, and whose sights are set on success beyond his homeland’s shores. That ambition ultimately lands him in America, within the corridors of some of the country’s most elite institutions. There’s a straightforward story here, a coming-of-age narrative with America as a shining beacon; and yet, given the novel’s principal setting — on an island nation off the coast of East Africa in the Indian Ocean — one hopes we might gain some greater understanding of humankind from the contrasts between the cultures and trajectories of these two starkly different countries. It’s an open question as to whether the story takes up that opportunity.
When the novel begins, Vishnu has returned to the island after 30 years to be at his ailing father’s bedside. His mother recounts his family’s rocky past — from abusive, arranged marriages to siblings battling over property — as it played out against the backdrop of a country beginning to fray at its racial and fiscal seams. Having long “straddled the working class and the lower middle class” in a socioeconomically, racially and linguistically stratified Mauritius, Vishnu’s Hindi-speaking family is ever angling for a higher station in life, with all their hopes now pinned on him.
So, we have our stakes. And yet, as the plot spools out in a relatively staid order — A then B then C, with some jumps in time and interludes of poetry — Vishnu never seems to engage with those stakes in any significant way; things simply happen, and we move on. Through dialogue, we learn of the family’s ancestral fall from grace, offhand commentary about pigmentation and the anglicizing of names, and surprising admiration for local remnants of French and British colonizers. But neither dialogue nor narration gives way to the characters’ interiority.
This absence is most jarring when the narrator approaches matters of colonialism, class or race as if they are neither good nor bad, but simply the way life is. When Vishnu’s father says a family friend “thinks an English name fits his skin color better,” Busjeet reveals no reaction on Vishnu’s part; the next sentence cuts to another scene. When we do glimpse his thoughts, they often lack depth. When Vishnu’s Mauritian friends predict his future success, “I smiled, but I didn’t know what to say,” Vishnu narrates. “Sure, my goal was to thrive among the elite. I was flattered, but what if I let them down?”
If there’s little of Vishnu’s inward life on the page, there’s certainly plenty of his surroundings. The middle of the novel takes us through natural disasters, political upheaval, bureaucratic corruption and economic instability. For readers unfamiliar with Mauritius, this history is illuminating, the richness of detail showcasing some of the best writing in the book. As Cyclone Carol menaces the island in 1960, Busjeet moves from a description of the marijuana the island’s Hindus partook in on happier occasions, to a sky stained blood-red by storm winds, then to a scrum of customers angling for a shop’s plywood and canned food, overseen by the savvy “white-haired Chinese woman counting on an abacus” while dispensing disaster survival advice. The tension in such moments is palpable enough to inject needed bits of fuel into the story.
Eventually, Vishnu arrives, in more ways than one. He wins a secondary school scholarship on the island, and later travels to London. He’s admitted to one Ivy League university and then another, securing several mentorships that give him contact highs off of old-money America. In several moments where he might be derailed — like when he’s assigned a work-study job he thinks is beneath him, in the kitchen of the Yale dining hall — Vishnu deploys the sort of slick, self-important persuasiveness many a political insider would kill for. While he occasionally overreaches and stumbles (in an entertaining sequence during a college internship in Washington, D.C., a single expensive dinner renders him penniless, forcing him back into the sort of kitchen job he’s previously avoided), Vishnu never second-guesses his ultimate goal of social status and material wealth. He’s most reflective when pridefully examining his “sookwaar,” or delicate, hands, in contrast to the callused hands of the working men around him; but the observation opens no door to deeper thoughts about inequity. Nor is there much room for nuance in Vishnu’s regard for the United States, which he blithely endorses, if not admires.
Is there anything wrong with this? It is a fantasy of the well-heeled that there’s something inherently noble or soul-validating to be found in blue-collar struggles with economic decay. A reasonable level of wealth, and the security and comfort it brings, remains a central goal for most of us, migrant or otherwise. But read in our current moment, when American pursuit — glorification, even — of excess has resulted in one of the most pernicious societies in modern history, Vishnu’s heedless pining for the one percent feels, at best, problematic. There are flashes in the final pages that he might be starting to realize this (“Was I at heart a non-materialist?” Vishnu ponders after failing to secure an investment banking job. “Or did I enjoy the good life that money brings?”), but they’re too ambivalent to count as a moral progression.
In the end, all of Vishnu’s striving leads exactly where we knew it would, as he’d alluded to it all along, narrating from adulthood. And yet, the story has been far from pointless. For one, it’s satisfying to read such a vivid rendering of a world unfamiliar to many. For another, bearing witness to a migratory rise in status gives one a sense of optimism, even if the reality is much more complicated than the novel suggests. That may be enough for many readers, even as the deeper insights into humanity and its heterogeneity remain elusive.
Site Information Navigation
Source: Read Full Article